Punch List for America– A Tool for Focusing Our Thinking and Conversation

Our civic time is a scarce resource. How do we allocate it? The norm, in my observation, is to defer to the media to decide what is most worth thinking about on any given day. What is the media bias? To get our attention by maximizing fear, by exaggerating the significance of something of marginal if any importance. It’s time to take control of our civic time allocation. How?
Turn off the media. Find a quiet place and a quiet time. Take out a pen and a piece of paper. Or open a word document and create a blank table or matrix with four columns
and seven rows.
1.) What issues matter most to you? These should be the row headings listed in
order of importance. Prioritization is everything in life. Civics is no different from
any other sphere. But prioritization is tough.
2.) The following question may help in this prioritization exercise: what is the biggest
gap between America as it is and America as it should be?
3.)That biggest gap should be the first row heading. The second biggest
the second and so on.
4.)  The column headings should be three categories of solutions:
say short term, medium term, long term. Or governmental, for profit, or non-profit.
Or federal, state, and local pending legislation. Or personal, family, community.
Or conceptual (re-framing), practical, fantasy. Or Best Idea, Second Best, Third Best.
Or Biggest bang for buck: #1, #2, #3
YOUR TURN: let’s trade Punch Lists. Let’s encourage our family members to
do so. Let’s set up Thinking Citizen Clubs in our communities where
Punch Lists are exchanged with a regular periodicity.
These constantly revised and edited Punch Lists should replace
media agendas as our algorithm for the allocation of our limited
civic time.

The American Dream: what is it? what is the biggest gap between it and America today?

How do you feel about the American Dream?
Write down your definition of the American dream.
Date it.
Share it.
Review and update it with a regular periodicity for the rest of your life. Share your updates with friends and family.
I strongly believe that every citizen should keep a thematic journal in order to prepare for decisions at the voting booth over the course of their lives. Continuity is key to depth of thought. With a regular periodicity, the journal notes should be consolidated into matrices that separate the essential from the inessential.

Do judges and juries matter any more?

Do Juries and Judges Matter anymore? How should the judicial system be changed?
1.) Today 95% of cases are resolved by plea bargaining (aka horse trading) between  prosecutors and defense attorneys. Jury trials are relatively rare.
2.) Should our judicial system be structured so that the odds of the guilty going free versus the innocent being unfairly punished be 2 to 1, 5 to 1,  10 to 1 (Bible, Blackstone),
100 to 1 (Maimonides), 1000 to 1?
3.) Is the civil law system better than the common law system? Is a system in which two lawyers twist the truth as best they can the best system for arriving at the real truth
and the fairest resolution?
4.) Should we abolish life tenure for judges? Cash bail?
Please share your thoughts.

What are the three most original ideas on this site?

1.) The Principles, Facts, and Solutions Matrix as the best civic literacy test.

2.) The Concepts and Examples Matrix as the best general education test for any discipline from physics and math to economics and ethics.

3.) The integrated vision of Seven Tools, Seven Disciplines and Seven Joys as an operational definition of the three aims of education: critical thinking, responsible citizenship, and well-roundedness.

The common theme is interactivity. And humility.

Welcome to the Liberal Arts Iron Man.

The math of democracies and republics

1) Democracy: 2 wolves and 1 lamb deciding what to have for dinner.

2) Republic: 200 wolves and 100 lambs voting for 2 wolves and 1 lamb to decide what to have for dinner

3) Constitutional Republic: A Constitution saying you can’t eat lamb but a Supreme Court made up of 5 wolves and 4 lambs deciding that mutton is not lamb.

Source: attribution unknown

Education First Policy: Three Thoughts

1.) Education is the key to our economy, our democracy, and our identity. Without rigorous training our economic potential will not be realized. Without civic literacy, true democracy is impossible. If our children are not taught to focus on the shared, the positive, and the future, their full humanity will not be reached.

2.) Education happens in homes, schools, and communities. Any strategy aimed at “fixing education” must address all three fronts.

3.) Education is not just about academics – it’s also about arts, athletics, and character. Equal schools means equally rigorous training programs in each of these “non-academic” areas.

Check out:

www.thinkingcitizen.com

and

www.educationfirstparty.com

Feedback much appreciated.